Navigation
(1) Concept (2) Origins: Spiritual, Gospel, and Blues (3) From Church to Stage: • Soloists • Small Ensembles • Large Choirs (4) Functions of Gospel in Modern Popular Music: • Performance • Vocal Expressiveness • Cinematography (5) Comparison (6) Conclusion
Concept
Gospel, as one of the principal musical genres to emerge from American culture, occupies a significant position in the history of contemporary pop culture. Its techniques have evolved into a universal expressive medium, one that is applied even outside of a religious context.Objective: To determine how the religious aesthetics of gospel are adapted to new formats beyond the church and which of its elements persist in contemporary music culture.Hypothesis: Gospel techniques outside of the church are becoming a universal expressive medium that aids in reinterpreting elements of religious aesthetics through musical and visual formats.The analysis of this research will draw from the intersection of four approaches: musical, visual, dramaturgical, and cultural-historical. This will allow for a thorough exploration of the topic, viewing gospel not merely as a musical genre, but as a part of a culture that shapes human understanding of concepts such as faith, freedom, unity, and self-expression.To illustrate the transition of gospel aesthetics into modernity, I will examine the works of Kanye West (Ye), Frank Ocean, and Labrinth’s soundtrack for the series «Euphoria.» Based on these artists, I will construct a system—each element representing a different context of the genre’s transformation, ranging from the music and the concert industry to vocal delivery and dramaturgy.
Origins. Spiritual, Gospel, and Blues
Blues is a pleasure to listen to—it is a song of despair. Gospel belongs to God—it is a song of hope.
Gospel (from the English Gospel music) is a genre of sacred Christian music that emerged in American culture at the end of the 19th century. Its roots trace back to Methodist churches in the American South, where African Americans gathered to praise God.
However, the foundations for the birth of gospel were laid on American plantations in the early 19th century. Slaves harvested cotton in the heat and lived in inhumane conditions. Their solace was singing in the fields and barracks—areas inaccessible to white people. Initially, these were field cries, known as «field hollers.» This is how the spiritual (from the English spiritual) originated, rooted in African musical traditions such as improvisation, collective singing, and polyrhythms.
Slaves fashioned instruments from whatever they could find: washing boards, tin cans, and fishing line. They sang about faith, God, and their difficult lot, even though they were forbidden from learning to read or write. This is why cultural memory was preserved through storytelling.
Slightly later, thanks to the development of musical instruments, the spiritual began to transform into gospel and blues (from the English blues, derived from blue devils—"melancholy»).
All three of these genres are closely intertwined, yet they possess key distinctions:
1) Theme: • Spiritual — Biblical narratives interwoven with harsh daily life • Gospel — Appeals to God, faith in salvation • Blues — Personal experiences, loneliness, unrequited love
2) Musical Structure: • Spiritual — Pentatonic scale, call-and-response form, polyrhythms, and a weak beat • Gospel — More complex harmonies and rhythms, crescendo, melismas, call-and-response form • Blues — 12-bar form, blues scale
3) Performance Style: • Spiritual — Communal singing • Gospel — Soloist and choir, high expressiveness and emotional intensity, with piano or organ accompaniment • Blues — Solo singing
It is also generally considered that gospel is a swingier and more modern evolution of the spiritual, while the blues is a more secularized form of the spiritual and gospel.
Thomas A. Dorsey (1945), image courtesy of the Hogan Jazz Archive, Tulane University
Thomas Andrew Dorsey is considered a pivotal figure in the history of gospel music, often called the «father of modern gospel.» It was after a profound personal tragedy that he wrote the iconic song, «Take My Hand, Precious Lord, ” which later became a genre standard and was covered by countless great artists, including Mahalia Jackson.
Precious Lord, take my hand
Lead me, allow me to rise
I am tired, I am weak, I am worn out
From Church to Stage. Soloists
Mahalia Jackson (1911–1972) was an American gospel singer widely regarded as the greatest performer of the genre throughout its history. She was also known as the «Queen of Gospel.»
The video features Mariah Jackson performing «Take My Hand, Precious Lord» accompanied by piano.Particular attention is paid to her phrasing and breath control. The end of the lines sounds like an emotional release, and her voice is very deep. Mariah actively employs crescendo and vibrato, lending density and dynamism to the performance.I also want to draw attention to her facial expressions and the emotionality of the song’s delivery. Mariah periodically lifts her gaze upward, as if addressing God. Her posture is fixed in a steady stance, and her clasped hands periodically open during the climax. It is this combination of physical restraint and musical emotion that creates the performance’s unique sound.The minimalistic, dark space surrounding the singer functions as a dramatic device. It emphasizes the performance itself, achieving a prayerful effect. Behind Mariah, there is set dressing resembling a stained-glass church window. This serves as a cultural marker, maintaining a connection to the ecclesiastical context.
Small groups
The Clara Ward Singers—one of the most successful and influential gospel groups in history—originated in 1931 as a family trio, led by Clara Ward.They were pioneers in using the technique of lead-switching, a style previously employed primarily by male gospel quartets.Another defining characteristic was their spectacular shows featuring vibrant costumes, elaborate decorations, and large wigs. However, it must be noted that this presentation attracted significant criticism; their performance style was often deemed «clownish» and insulting to the African American heritage.Songs such as «Surely God Is Able, ” „How I Got Over, ” and „Packin' Up“ became the group’s signature hits.
The video captures the group’s performance of the song «A City Called Heaven» at Ed Sullivan’s Show in 1969.
The group employs active vocalist switching, creating a sense of building dynamic tension. This technique, combined with energetic dancing and chaotic leaps, evokes the feeling of a mini-theatrical production where the audience is not only listening to the music but observing a full-fledged performance.
A question-and-answer dynamic is also actively used, preserving the sense of a lively dialogue.
The overall dynamic of the performance appears quite chaotic—featuring emotional peaks and valleys, culminating in a pronounced climax.
The group’s stage persona transcends the notion of a modest, church-based presentation. Vibrant dresses, elaborate hairstyles, expressive facial expressions, and sharp gestures cultivate an almost theatrical atmosphere.
Large Choirs
Youth for Christ Choir was a youth choir led by Pastor Thomas Lee Barrett. This project originated from weekly gatherings at Barrett’s church in Chicago during the late 1960s and early 1970s. The group consisted of about 40 teens aged 12–19. Their music blended gospel with other contemporary genres, such as soul, R&B, funk, and more. The uniqueness of their sound lay in its rich harmonic content and powerful drumming.
In 1971, the album «Like a Ship (Without a Sail)» was released. The first song from this album, which shares the same title, belongs to the gospel genre but features a pronounced influence of soul and funk. This was a distinguishing characteristic of Chicago gospel in the 1970s.This work explores themes of hope, self-discovery, and social issues:
But I am not worried because I know I know I know that we can get through this I know that we will handle it
I want to point out how the funky rhythm makes the composition more danceable and versatile outside of a church context.
The rhythm serves as a foundation that holds the listener’s attention. Accented beats, bright instrumental parts, and a call-and-response structure all play a vital role.
Using this composition as an example, it is clear how traditional gospel techniques can be combined with funky rhythms to create a new sound that is universally applicable in modern pop music.
This is precisely why Kanye West sampled the track «Father I Stretch My Hands» by the Youth for Christ Choir on his album The Life of Pablo, subsequently increasing the project’s national recognition in the 2010s.
The Function of the Gospel in Modern Popular Music. Performance
Kanye West (Ye) is an American rapper, music producer, and entrepreneur. He is one of the most authoritative and controversial figures in contemporary culture.His connection to gospel music is rooted in two key moments of his career: the release of the album «Jesus Is King» and the launch of his side project, «Sunday Service.»The ninth studio album is based on Christian themes, creating a stark contrast with his previous work. Kanye West himself described the album as «an expression of the Gospel.»
Above is a recording from one of the performances of the «Sunday Service» project. It is important to note that these performances are not perceived like a typical concert. These events feature a large choir, and the music includes both Kanye’s original songs and covers. He shares stories from his personal experience and discusses thoughts on faith, which makes the show more intimate.
The song «Follow God» from the album «Jesus Is King» touches upon themes of faith and the relationship with God.
Kanye stands at the center, encircled by the choir. The choir members are dressed in white, symbolizing purity, unity, and spirituality.
We should also point out the musical interplay between the artist and the choir: dialogues frequently emerged, characteristic of the call-and-response format found in gospel music. The choir members move actively—raising their hands and clapping. This enhances the feeling of scale and unity.
The space around the stage is decorated with flowers, which serves as part of the symbolic system. Flowers often represent renewal and inner spiritual growth—a contrast, of course, to the artist’s usual image.




