Original size 1182x1600

Who is the author of the copy. Authorship in network art from Duchamp to neural networks

PROTECT STATUS: not protected
This project is a student project at the School of Design or a research project at the School of Design. This project is not commercial and serves educational purposes
The project is taking part in the competition

Navigation: [0] Concept [1] Attribution as a Gesture [2] Variation and Community [3] Delegating Authorship [4] Conclusion

Visual Research Concept

Net art emerged within an environment structured as a copying machine. The browser displays the source code of a page, and the screenshot transforms someone else’s work into material for one’s own—thus, the question of authorship confronts anyone who forwards or remixes an image.The conventional understanding of originality linked the value of a work to a singular object and a singular author. Duchamp and Sherrie Levine questioned this schema long before the internet, but the network turned appropriation from a risky gesture into a daily practice. Now, it must be studied using material that last-century authorship theorists never knew.

This research seeks to answer the question of how the understanding of originality and authorship has changed in appropriation practices from the pre-internet era through to neural networks, and what remains of the original when a work exists in a chain of versions.

The hypothesis is that originality alters its nature. Initially, it relies on a gesture attributable to a specific name. Then, it shifts to the artwork’s position within a chain of copies. Eventually, the right to control variation moves from the artist to the platform. If this is true, the differences between periods should be evident in who is named as the author and what is considered proprietary.

The work is divided into three chapters based on the type of authorship present. In the first chapter, attribution remains a gesture with a recognizable author. In the second, authorship dissolves into the community, and the work lives on as a variation. In the third, the concept of authorship shifts toward the instruction or the program, and subsequently toward the token. A chronological framework is maintained within each chapter. Six examples are examined—two from each of the three time periods, ranging from pre-internet to today. This evolution is visible through direct comparison within each chapter, positioning the golden age of net art in the middle of the work. Each example is analyzed using a single framework: determining the source material and who is ultimately credited as the author, followed by comparing the outcome with an example from an adjacent period.

Visual material was selected with the intention of citing the source and version whenever possible. The selection includes cases that are easily identifiable—for instance, a reproduction of a Walker Evans photograph or the documenta X website. The notoriety of the work was not the primary criterion; rather, the clarity of how the author’s position shifts proved more important. Museum works were deliberately placed alongside anonymous productions because the boundary between them becomes a subject of analysis in itself. Comparisons are built in pairs. Levin and Prince are compared because their procedures are almost identical, yet their contexts are different. LeWitt and Cohen are compared because one addresses the instruction to a person, while the other addresses it to a machine. This selection process has limits. Many network works have been lost or are only accessible in archival versions, requiring us to judge them based on descriptions and screenshots. Therefore, the material studied is not necessarily typical of its era.Textual sources were chosen so that each addresses a specific part of the argumentation. The works of Barthes and Foucault help examine the concept of authorship, while research on art from the second half of the 20th century explains the evolution of appropriation. Particular attention is paid to the theories of remix, new media, and internet culture. The artists' texts and interviews supplement the theoretical framework, and legal and news materials illustrate how the law responds to image appropriation. Contemporary research into generative art helps trace the evolution of this theme up to the present day.

Assignment as a Gesture

Attribution as a gesture implies that the selected foreign material has a recognizable author for the selection, and the meaning of that choice depends on that author. Each chapter example reads as an answer to the question of what originality entails when the object itself is taken from another. The six cases progress chronologically. Before the internet, the gesture was directed at the object and the image. In the Golden Age, it addressed the interface and the institution. In our day, it shifts toward the platform and the automated archive.

Original size 3214x2098

Duchamp’s «Fountain» became an exemplar of a gesture in which the artist does almost nothing with his hands. The urinal was submitted to the exhibition of the Society of Independent Artists under the pseudonym R. Mutt and was rejected, even though the exhibition rules did not include a jury. The original is no longer preserved. The work is known through a photograph by Stieglitz, published in The Blind Man magazine, and through 1960s replicas. It appears that this benchmark work on the rejection of the unique object exists as a chain of copies, and its authenticity was assigned retroactively. Krauss shows that the concept of avant-garde originality relies on the exclusion of repetition, and «Fountain» literally confirms this.

Originality is localized in the selection action and the name, not in the subject.

Original size 3214x2098

Sherrie Levine takes the next step in her series «After Walker Evans.» She photographs reproductions of Evans’s images and presents them under her own name without making any alterations. Duchamp chose a ready-made object, while Levine chooses an image that is already a copy, because she is working with the printed reproduction rather than the original print.

Original size 3214x2098

Krimp views this re-photographing as a technique that dismantles the notion of the photographer as the source of the image. Benjamin explains why this is possible—because the mass-reproduced copy lacks the aura that can be stolen. It is telling that a canonical author is assigned, whose name carries more weight in the art world than Levin’s own. This gesture works because of that contrast. The debate about authorship continues, but it is now directed toward the ownership of the image itself.

Original size 1800x678
Original size 1800x678
Original size 3214x2098
Loading...

In the latter half of the nineties, the concept shifts to the interface. Jodi’s work at wwwwwwwww.jodi.org does not appropriate an existing picture or photograph; instead, it appropriates the environment in which the page opens. The visitor sees green text on a black background, reminiscent of a system error, and the hidden navigation transforms the page into a puzzle without instructions. Driba describes this structure as something that at first glance is easily mistaken for a computer virus, while noting that it does not harm the user. The material is appropriated not from a specific author, but from the technology itself—meaning the browser and the system error, which belong to everyone and no one.

Original size 1914x888
Original size 1200x386

The author of the original photograph, Lev, is known and credited, but the one presented here is anonymous, so we cannot say where it originated. Originality shifts from the selection of the subject to the skill of interpreting the tool differently than its creators intended.

Original size 1800x578

Vuk Kosmich showed another way of assigning [meaning/value] in the same years. In 1997, the organizers of the documenta X exhibition announced that its website would be closed and its materials released on CD-ROM. Kosmich copied a significant portion of the website to his own server and distributed a partly fictional press release. In an interview with Connor, he recalls that he himself was not included in the exhibition, but Hit Banting and Jodi were selected from his circle. Documenta Done (Fig. 4) appropriates not an image, but the institutional website as a whole, along with the exhibition’s name and reputation. The copy was precise, which raises the question of which of the two versions is the original. The answer depends on what one considers the original—the content or its place within the institution. Kosmich himself called the work the result of a collaboration between Duchamp and Debord, and this is an accurate description. From Duchamp, there is the selection of a ready-made object; from Debord, the orientation against the prevailing order. Driga refers to the network ready-made «Radiomixer» by Sergei Kotsun, which mixes internet radio stations, and Documenta Done can be understood analogously—only the entire exhibition becomes the ready-made object.

Original size 1800x578
Original size 1235x612
Who is the author of the copy. Authorship in network art from Duchamp to neural networks
Project created at 17.11.2026
designschool.am
designschool.am — цифровая экосистема, объединяющая профессиональное портфолио для дизайнеров — студентов, выпускников и сотрудников программы «Коммуникационный дизайн» (совместный проект Российско-Армянского Университета и Школы дизайна НИУ ВШЭ), образовательную онлайн-платформу, площадку, агрегирующую международные онлайн-конкурсы в креативных индустриях и другие профессиональные инструменты.... Show more
We use cookies to improve the operation of the website and to enhance its usability. More detailed information on the use of cookies can be fo...
Show more